When NGO budgets are tight, how can we prove the value of communications?

Dr Deepti Bhargava (APR, FPRINZ), Senior Lecturer and Head of Department, Advertising & Brand Creativity, Digital Communication and Public Relations at Auckland University of Technology (AUT)

When budgets are tight and resources are thin, every part of an organisation is under pressure to demonstrate its value. Communications is, of course, no exception - and it can sometimes be one of the first functions to face cuts.

For NGO and charity communications teams, being able to demonstrate value means understanding what communications is achieving, why particular activity is being prioritised, what is working and where investment is making a difference.

Measurement and evaluation have an important role to play.

I spoke to Dr Deepti Bhargava (APR, FPRINZ), Senior Lecturer and Head of Department, Advertising & Brand Creativity, Digital Communication and Public Relations at Auckland University of Technology (AUT), about how communications teams can get better at demonstrating the value of their work.

For Deepti, measurement and evaluation are ultimately about making better decisions.

“Measurement tells us what happened and gives us evidence about the results of our communications planning and tactical efforts,” she says. “Evaluation helps us interpret that information, understand why it matters, and decide what we should continue, change or do differently next time.”

That means measurement isn't simply about producing a set of numbers at the end of a campaign. It is about gathering evidence that can help communications teams understand what is working, demonstrate their contribution and make decisions about where to put resources next.

Don't start with the numbers

One of the biggest mistakes communications teams can make, according to Deepti, is starting with the metrics rather than the objectives.

It's easy to report impressions, reach, media coverage and engagement because those numbers are readily available.

But what do they actually tell us?

“Someone seeing a message doesn’t mean they understood it. Understanding it doesn’t mean their attitude changed. And a change in attitude doesn’t necessarily mean they acted.”

Reach and engagement can be useful measures, but they are only part of the picture as neither of those figures, on its own, tells you whether your communication achieved its purpose.

Instead, communications teams should start by asking: What are we trying to achieve and which metrics would help us understand if we did that?

Deepti recommends starting all communication planning with formative research. This helps you understand the context, inform your strategy, establish a baseline, set SMART objectives and identify relevant measures that align with those objectives. When it comes to measurement and evaluation, you can then assess the extent to which your objectives have been achieved.

In practice, that means being specific about the change you want to see.

The point is to decide what success looks like before you start, rather than trying to work out what the numbers mean afterwards.

Connect communications to the organisation's goals

The strongest case for communications is made when it is clearly connected to what the organisation is trying to achieve.

Deepti recommends working backwards from the organisation’s goals. Start by identifying what the organisation wants to achieve, then consider what communication needs to achieve to contribute to those goals.

If the goal is fundraising, for example, communication objectives might aim to reach prospective donors, increase their understanding of the need, build trust, cultivate an interest in donating and ultimately contribute to donations.

Similarly, if the goal is to advocate for policy change, communication objectives might aim to reach policymakers and relevant stakeholders, increase their understanding of the issue and the need for policy change, build their support for the proposed change, encourage stakeholders to take action (such as making public submissions), and ultimately contribute to policy reform and wider societal benefits.

The exact measures will depend on the organisation, but the principle is the same:

Don't measure communications activity for its own sake. Measure the change that activity is intended to contribute to.

Deepti suggests thinking about measurement across four stages:

  • Reach (outputs): Did we reach the people we wanted to reach?

Metrics could be circulation, impressions, share of voice, views, open rates, unique website visitors etc.

  • Response (out-takes): How did they respond? Did awareness, interest, understanding or engagement change?

Metrics might include unprompted recall, follower growth, engagement rates or positive sentiment in comments.

  • Effect (outcomes): Did attitudes, satisfaction, trust or intentions change?

Metrics might include improved satisfaction ratings, reduced criticism or negative coverage or even actions such as enquiries, registrations and subscriptions.

  • Results (impact): Did the changes in communication reach, response and effect make a meaningful difference to stakeholder relationships and behaviours, societal outcomes, and/or organisational results?

Metrics might include increased donations, policy change following sustained advocacy, or volunteer growth or retention.

Importantly, she doesn't suggest every NGO should measure everything.

“Choose what is relevant and corresponds directly to the change you are trying to achieve,” she says.

Being intentional with a limited budget

For communications teams already stretched for time and resources, measurement can sound like another expensive piece of work. But it doesn't have to be.

Good measurement and evaluation does require investment, but nonprofits can do this more economically by making the most of existing data and taking a focused, intentional approach to collecting evidence, ensuring that the process is both meaningful and efficient.

Depending on the objective, this could include a simple pre- and post-campaign survey or even a specific question in an Omnibus survey, stakeholder interviews, search, social media or website analytics, enquiries, subscriptions, CRM or fundraising data, information from partner organisations or public sector reports, volunteer records, media analysis or behavioural data.

The important thing is to choose the method based on what you need to find out.

If you want to know whether awareness has changed, a survey might help.

If you want to understand why stakeholders responded in a particular way, interviews or focus groups may be more useful.

If you want to understand whether communications contributed to an action, website or CRM data may provide evidence.

Often, combining quantitative and qualitative information will give you a much better picture than relying on one metric alone.

Another important consideration is establishing a baseline before the campaign begins.

As Deepti explains, otherwise you may know where you ended up, but not necessarily what changed or whether your communication contributed to that change.

Make measurement useful to senior leaders

When it comes to reporting results to CEOs, boards and funders, Deepti recommends focusing on insight rather than a long list of metrics.

Decision-makers want to know: What were we trying to achieve? What contribution did communications make? What did it cost? What did we learn? And what should we do next?

That means translating communications results into the language of the organisation.

Instead of simply reporting that you achieved 50 pieces of media coverage, explain what that coverage meant.

Was the media coverage positive and did it convey the relevant key messages? Did it reach the right audience? Did it increase awareness and understanding of the issue? Did it lead to greater stakeholder engagement? Did it contribute to improved trust in the organisation’s advocacy work? Over time, did such coverage help strengthen the organisation’s reputation and build public support?

The aim isn't to show everything you measured. It's to give decision-makers the evidence they need to understand the contribution communications is making and make informed choices about future investment.

Start with one question

For teams without the time or budget for a sophisticated measurement programme, Deepti has a simple starting point:

“What do we want to be different among this key public as a result of this communication?”

That question can help shape the objective, the communication activity and the evaluation from the outset.

It also provides a useful test for deciding what is worth measuring. When resources are limited, there is little value in collecting data simply because it is available.

Instead, communications teams can focus their attention on the evidence that helps them understand whether their work is contributing to the organisation's priorities.

For NGOs, that evidence can be important not only for demonstrating results, but for making decisions about where limited communications resources are best spent.

Because when budgets are under pressure, being able to show what communications is achieving, what is working and what should happen next is increasingly part of the job.

Deepti recommends these best-practice guides in measurement and evaluation:

Barcelona Principles: https://amecorg.com/amec-resources-centre-communication-measurement-evaluation-tools/barcelona-principles-4-0/

AMEC Interactive framework: https://amecorg.com/amecframework/framework/interactive-framework/

Advice from the Public Relations Institute of New Zealand: https://prinz.org.nz/measurement-and-evaluation/

Next
Next

What’s actually changed? How Outcome Harvesting can show the impact of our work